- In 2008, received National Board of Review Award for Best Ensemble Cast
- In 2008, received Independent Spirit Award for Best Male Lead
- In 2007, received Boston Society of Film Critics Award for Best Ensemble Cast
- In 2006, received Academy Award for Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role
- In 2006, received BAFTA Award for Best Actor
- In 2006, received Golden Globe Award for Best Actor in a Motion Picture (Drama)
- In 2006, received Independent Spirit Award for Best Male Lead
- In 2006, received National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Actor
- In 2006, received Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading Role
- In 2006, received Broadcast Film Critics' Choice Award for Best Actor
- In 2005, received Toronto Film Critics Award for Best Actor
- In 2005, received Boston Film Critics Award for Best Actor
- In 2005, received National Board of Review Award for Best Actor
- In 2005, received Los Angeles Film Critics Award for Best Actor
- In 2000, received Theatre World Award
- In 1999, received National Board of Review Award for Best Supporting Actor
- In 1998, received National Board of Review Award for Best Ensemble Performance
