Family
- father Skip Taylor:
- mother Joan Taylor:
- daughter Ella Olivia: Born April 10, 2002; father, Ben Stiller
- son Quinlin Dempsey Stiller: Born July 10, 2005; father, Ben Stiller
- brother Brian Taylor:
Companions
- Billy McCaffrey: former Duke University basketball star; attended high school with Taylor
- David Lascher: dated while co-starring on the Nickelodeon series "Hey Dude" in the late 1980s- early 1990s; no longer together
- Jason Bloom: engaged as of September 1996; son of entertainment laywer Jake Bloom; born c. 1968; no longer together
- Matthew Lillard: dated c. 1991
